Disputes

Challenged claims, with the objection and the outcome. Challenges come from our own cross-vendor audits and from readers. Upheld disputes are corrected or removed; both-defensible cases are documented and left unchanged; not-upheld objections are answered.

To dispute an edge, open its citation in the atlas, press dispute, and file the report as a GitHub issue. A dispute must say what the cited paragraph says; reports that do not are closed as incomplete.

To confirm an edge, check the cited paragraph in any edition and press confirm. Confirmations enter the edge's public verification record.

Disputes

Reader confirmations